Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Decorating Dilemma

I'm participating in a Decorating Dilemma Party at http://serenitynow4amanda.blogspot.com/2009/09/decorating-dilemmas-partyround-2.html.
Come check out the fun!!
I have two dilemmas. Ok, I have like a thousand, but I don't want to overwhelm! :)
Here is our dining room.





It is very close to the living room, so I have used black accents to decorate in both rooms. Here is dilemma #1: Should I paint the dining room table? If so, what color? Would it be too dark to do it black? Should I be really brave and do it white? AAHH!! I have no clue!

Here is dilemma #2:


I LOVE our fireplace. It is beautiful! I would love to buy a new fireplace surround to replace that glaringly ugly brass, but we can't afford it right now. My husband thinks that if I try and paint the surround, I will have a hard time making it look "right." He thinks we should just leave it until we can afford a new one. I, on the other hand, think I can do it!! I want to paint it black. Anybody have any input? Has anybody done it? Help me please!!

12 comments:

  1. I say go for painting the table and chairs black. I'm considering doing that with mine, too. Someday. ;-) But I think it would look just fine. As far as the surround...I don't know anything about them but you can paint just about anything. I say go for it!! Good luck!

    Nancy

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi there! I just posted about my Pottery Barn knock-off set that I made from hand-me-down chairs and a flea market table. I'm posting specific directions on Friday. The post is here (with pictures of course!)...http://songbirdtiff.blogspot.com/2009/08/pottery-barn-inspired-kitchen-table.html


    Your fireplace mantle is beautiful! I know I have read about people painting their brass surrounds, so I know it can be done. It may just require a bit of research. If you find good info, share it with your hubby. Maybe he'll get on board with it.

    Thanks for sharing! (visiting from the Serenity Now party)

    ReplyDelete
  4. I say be brave and paint it white or a light feather gray. Holly at life in the fun lane has lots of examples of this. she recently just did a table almost exactly like that one!
    I love the mantle. I know you can paint the brass-there are a few really good sprays like 1-2-3 primer.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh, DEFINITELY paint the table and chairs black! It will look gorgeous! I think white would make the whole room look too pale, kind of washed out.

    For the fireplace surround, instead of a stark black I LOVE the spray paint color "oil rubbed bronze". It's beautiful and dark, with just a hint of a bronze/mettalic sheen.

    I think it would match the other colors really well.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'd totally go for painting your DR set, and then maybe add a "mistreatment" (to quote the Nester) to your big window.

    You CAN paint that surround. I know Sarah at Thrifty Decor Chick has done it (if you check her out be sure to tell her I sent you). :) I think you just have to use a special high heat paint.

    I like Xazmin's suggestion of the oil rubbed bronze. That would be pretty! I love the wall color by the fireplace. Very pretty. :)

    Thanks so much for joining the party. Hope you are having fun visiting the other blogs too. :) See you at the next party! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I wouldn't paint the table black - the room seems small and it might make it rather dark - how about a grey or antique white? Also try a tablecloth on the table in the color you want to paint and see what you think.

    Be careful painting the brass - get something that is heat resistant and fireproof!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I say paint the table! Either black or white would be nice! I wish I could paint our table, because if I could I would! hahaha It is Mike's parents.

    And I say paint the fireplace! You definitely need something that will hold up to the high heat. I think black will be perfect!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Paint it all black!

    Really, black table sets are really popular right now (they are a pain to dust, but so striking). You could always just paint the chair backs and legs and the table legs, to give a classic country vibe, then go ll out black if you decide to later on.

    I would either paint the surround (if you can remove it, you could spray paint it with outdoor grill paint), or buy/make a fireplace screen. We have brass on our surround (not quite as much as you) and my parents bought us a screen as an anniversary present last year - it has made a huge impact in the room.

    :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Based on the style of the dining set and the bright color you chose for the walls, I would paint the table white then you could top it with a black trey and some pops of yellow (?). It will also tie in nicely with the white of the mantle. Afterwards, I would think about getting a rug for the room to anchor everything- probably in a neutral color.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I always lean more towards white, but black would be nice, too.

    I say paint the brass!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think the dining room table would look great either black or white--I tend to think that the black would really pop against your wall color, though.

    And you can totally paint that fireplace surround--have you ever seen the Southern Hospitality blog? She has painted all sorts of fixtures. I have a link to her on my blog--check it out and she has great instructions. I say paint it!!! :-D

    ReplyDelete